When Norse settlers came to Iceland around 874 AD, apparently they brought trolls with them. Indeed, trolls appear frequently in written Norse folklore, drawing on a much older oral tradition. One such story concerns the ninth-century Norwegian poet Bragi Boddason’s encounter with a troll woman. It was recorded in The Poesy of Skalds (Skáldskaparmál), part of Snorri Sturluson’s Prose Edda, in the early 13th century. The surrounding work is really long, but this encounter is only two verses: a troll woman approaches Bragi in a forest, and the two introduce themselves in verse. Apparently, a simple “Hello” wasn’t sufficient.
A great source for old Icelandic troll stories is this website, although you’ll need your browser to translate the stories from Icelandic. One classic you can find there is that of Reynisdrangar, which explains the rock formations that you can still see today off the coast near Vík. In one familiar version, trolls attempt to pull a ship to shore, but get caught at sunrise and turn to stone. In the version on that website, a troll woman asks for passage on a ship and is denied. She curses the ship to turn to stone, and the king’s son returns the curse, turning her to stone as well.

Another intriguing story is The Night Troll, which tells the tale of a girl who volunteers to stay at a farmhouse on Christmas Eve, caring for a baby while the rest of the household attends church. She exchanges verses with a troll at the window until dawn, when, you guessed it, he turns to stone.
Turning to stone is a recurring theme for trolls, as is the throwing of enormous rocks. Such stories provided handy explanations for many of the odd rock formations people encountered in Iceland. Sure, we can describe those landscapes in terms of volcanic activity, glaciers, and erosion, but geological explanations don’t have nearly as much personality as a petrified troll, do they?
When you are trying to make sense of a strange world, a story can give you something to hold on to. There are other possible reasons why trolls gained a foothold in Norse culture in general and in Iceland specifically. Here are just a few theories that I have.
From campfire stories to the popular Friday the 13th movie franchise, it’s clear that many people like being scared. And trolls are scary. Fear can be entertaining. These stories were probably a great way to pass a long, cold, stormy night. But also, when you live in a harsh, unforgiving landscape, you don’t want your children running off alone, especially at night. You want to keep them a bit more cautious than that, when hypothermia or falling to their deaths is an actual possibility.
Before we poke too much fun at Icelanders for such stories, don’t forget that we ourselves have a “jolly old elf” in the form of Saint Nick, or Santa Claus, who teaches children to be good for goodness’ sake. And the Icelanders have a troll for that. She’s called Grýla, and she’s a fearsome troll mother who eats badly behaved children. (Okay, so that’s a bit worse than getting a lump of coal in your stocking, but still.) Parts of that scary folklore have lightened up over time. Although Grýla retains her taste for naughty children, her 13 sons, the Yule Lads, have become a lot friendlier. These days, they’re apparently not interested in eating children, and they either leave treats or potatoes in children’s shoes.

I can also think of another purpose for trolls. When you live in an environment where the odds are stacked against you, I imagine it’s easy to get discouraged. It must be hard to have to constantly worry about accumulating enough food to see you through the winter in such a barren landscape. It must be devastating to work so hard, only to have one disaster put you back to square one. So having stories that show human beings being able to outwit and survive encounters with creatures much stronger and more hostile than themselves might have provided a much-needed pep talk when times were tough. “See? We Icelanders are made of sterner stuff than this! We’ll make it!”
Trolls also make great scapegoats. When the sh*t hits the fan, it’s nice to be able to blame a troll. And it’s even nicer when you can convince yourself that it really is the fault of a troll. Because f**k a bunch of trolls!
One thing that I can tell you from personal experience: When you are in Northeast Iceland, and you’ve had a fever for days, and it’s 30 degrees Fahrenheit and the wind is howling and it’s raining and there’s nothing but lava fields for miles, and there seems to be no other living creature on the face of the earth, and no source of help or comfort, and the sun is setting, and you don’t know what to do, it’s easy to start thinking you see movement out of the corner of your eye. It’s easy to think rock formations might be something else.
And at a time like that, it’s easy to remember that on the ride from the airport 6 days previously, you whispered something snarky and disrespectful to Dear Husband about your assumption that these Icelanders actually believe in trolls, of all things, and how ridiculous is that? And then you realize that every single plan you’ve made has been sh*tting the bed ever since. Maybe someone, or something overheard you.
A true believer will find evidence of trolls throughout my entire trip. You’ll see, Dear Reader. You’ll see…


Leave a Reply